top of page

The Frog and the Nightingale
by Vikram Seth

Summary

​

"The Frog and the Nightingale" is a satirical poem by Vikram Seth that explores themes of manipulation, exploitation, artistic integrity, and the consequences of succumbing to external pressures. The narrative follows the interactions between a frog, known for his loud but uninspiring croaking, and a talented nightingale whose beautiful singing captivates the entire bog.

Initially, the nightingale's arrival brings joy and admiration from the other creatures, contrasting starkly with the frog's abrasive presence. However, the frog, motivated by his own desires for profit and recognition, manipulates the nightingale into a partnership, promising success and guidance. Despite her natural talent, the nightingale's confidence wanes as she succumbs to the frog's demands for perfection, ultimately leading to her demise.

Through this allegorical tale, Seth critiques the dangers of conforming to societal expectations and sacrificing one's authenticity for the sake of external validation. The frog symbolizes those who exploit others for personal gain, while the nightingale represents artists who compromise their integrity in pursuit of success. The poem serves as a cautionary tale against the perils of losing oneself in the pursuit of fame and the importance of staying true to one's own voice and identity.

What is the lesson depicted in the poem The Frog and the Nightingale?

​

The poem "The Frog and the Nightingale" by Vikram Seth conveys several lessons, including:

  • Individuality and Authenticity: The nightingale's downfall is a result of her attempt to conform to the frog's standards and please the audience. The poem highlights the importance of staying true to one's own voice and not compromising individuality for the sake of approval.

  • Manipulation and Exploitation: The frog represents individuals who exploit others for personal gain. The nightingale's tragic fate serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of blindly following the advice of others without considering one's own well-being.

  • Artistic Integrity: The poem explores the conflict between commercial success and artistic integrity. The nightingale's pursuit of applause and popularity, at the expense of her own artistic vision, leads to her ultimate demise. It emphasizes the importance of maintaining one's artistic principles.

  • Critique of Conformity: The poem critiques the societal tendency to conform to mediocre standards rather than appreciating true talent. The nightingale's melodious voice is overshadowed by the frog's loud but unremarkable croaking, reflecting the sometimes misguided preferences of the masses.

  • Consequences of Naivety: The nightingale's trusting and naive nature contributes to her downfall. The poem suggests the importance of being discerning and critical, especially when receiving advice or facing external pressures.

    • Overall, the poem serves as a reflection on human behaviour, the pitfalls of conformity, and the importance of maintaining one's authenticity and individuality in the face of external expectations.

    CHARACTERS

    1. Frog

    2. Nightingale

    3. Ducks

    4. Herons

    5. Loon

    6. Toads

    7. Teals

    8. Tiddlers

    9. Owl of Sandwich

    10. Duck of Kent

    11. Mallard

    12. Milady Trent

    13. Martin Cardinal Mephisto

    14. Coot of Monte Cristo

    1. Frog: The central character of the poem, known for his loud croaking in Bingle Bog.

    2. Nightingale: Another central character, whose melodious singing captivates the other creatures in the bog.

    3. Ducks: Birds that inhabit the bog and are among the creatures enchanted by the nightingale's singing.

    4. Herons: Another type of bird found in the bog, also drawn to the nightingale's song.

    5. Loon: A type of bird that weeps beneath the summer moon, moved by the nightingale's performance.

    6. Toads: Similar to frogs, these creatures inhabit the bog and are likely familiar with the frog's croaking.

    7. Teals: Small freshwater ducks that may be part of the audience enchanted by the nightingale.

    8. Tiddlers: Likely referring to small fish or aquatic creatures found in the bog, also entranced by the nightingale's singing.

    9. Owl of Sandwich: A humorous reference to an owl character, possibly named after a location, indicating the diverse audience drawn by the nightingale's performance.

    10. Duck of Kent: Another duck character, named after a region, further emphasizing the varied audience captivated by the nightingale.

    11. Mallard: Another type of duck that enjoys the nightingale's performance.

    12. Milady Trent: A noble-sounding title given to a character, possibly representing a distinguished figure in the bog's community.

    13. Martin Cardinal Mephisto: An elaborately named character, likely a combination of different bird species or titles, adding to the whimsical nature of the poem.

    14. Coot of Monte Cristo: A play on words, combining the name of a bird species (coot) with the title of the famous novel "The Count of Monte Cristo," adding a literary reference to the diverse audience enchanted by the nightingale.

    These animals serve to enrich the setting of the poem and highlight the universal appeal of the nightingale's song, drawing creatures from various backgrounds and species to listen and admire her talent.

    Top of Form

    Discuss the following questions and write the answers in your notebooks.

    ​

    a. Bring out the irony in the frog's statement - 'Your song must be your own'.

    b. Do you think that the end of the poem is justified?

    c. Do you think the nightingale is 'brainless'? Give reasons for your answer.

    d. In spite of having a melodious voice and being a crowd puller, the nightingale turns out to be a loser and dies. How far is she responsible for her own downfall?

    e. Do you agree with the Frog's inference of the Nightingale's character? Give reasons for your answer

    a. Irony in the frog's statement - 'Your song must be your own': The irony lies in the fact that while the frog insists that the nightingale's song must be her own, he manipulates and exploits her talent for his gain. The frog, with his limited and cacophonous croaking, represents conformity and mediocrity, yet he imposes his standards on the nightingale. The nightingale, in her attempt to please and conform, loses her uniqueness and eventually perishes. The frog's statement becomes ironic because he suppresses the very individuality he claims to champion.

    ​

    b. Justification of the end of the poem: The end of the poem is justified in the sense that it serves as a cautionary tale about the consequences of sacrificing one's true self for the sake of approval and conformity. The nightingale's tragic end underscores the dangers of succumbing to external pressures and losing one's authenticity. It highlights the importance of staying true to oneself, even in the face of criticism and expectations.

    ​

    c. Is the nightingale 'brainless'?: No, the nightingale is not 'brainless.' Her downfall is not due to her lack of intelligence but rather her vulnerability to external influence and her desire for approval. She is a victim of manipulation by the frog, who exploits her talent for his own gain. The nightingale's tragic fate is a result of her naivety and the pressure to conform to the frog's standards, not her lack of intelligence.

    ​

    d. Nightingale's responsibility for her downfall: The nightingale is partially responsible for her downfall because she allows herself to be swayed by the frog's opinions and desires for commercial success. Her eagerness to please and conform, coupled with her lack of assertiveness, leads her to compromise her artistic integrity. However, the primary responsibility lies with the manipulative frog, who takes advantage of her vulnerability and pushes her to her limits.

    ​

    e. Agreement with the Frog's inference of the Nightingale's character: No, one should not fully agree with the Frog's inference of the Nightingale's character. The frog sees the nightingale as 'stupid' and 'far too nervous,' but these qualities are more indicative of her innocence and vulnerability. The nightingale's downfall is a result of her trusting nature and her willingness to follow the frog's misguided advice. The frog's assessment is biased and self-serving, designed to deflect blame from his own exploitative actions.

    Extra Questions from the lesson:

    1. How does the frog initially respond to the nightingale's arrival in the bog?

    2. What promises does the frog make to the nightingale to convince her to collaborate?

    3. What are some of the criticisms the frog offers about the nightingale's singing?

    4. How does the nightingale's behavior change as she becomes more involved with the frog?

    5. What role does the audience's reaction play in the nightingale's performances?

    6. What is the significance of the nightingale's exhaustion and eventual demise?

    7. How does the frog rationalize the nightingale's death?

    8. What themes does Vikram Seth explore through the characters of the frog and the nightingale?

    9. What does the poem suggest about the nature of artistic integrity and authenticity?

    10. How does the ending of the poem reflect the broader message conveyed by Seth?

    Answers to the extra questions:

    Answers to the extra questions:

    1. Initially, the frog responds to the nightingale's arrival with surprise and curiosity, as her melodious singing contrasts with his own harsh croaking.

    2. The frog promises the nightingale fame, success, and guidance in honing her singing skills, suggesting that together they can achieve greatness and profit from her talent.

    3. Some criticisms the frog offers about the nightingale's singing include that it lacks force, certain techniques are lacking, and her performances are too long.

    4. As the nightingale becomes more involved with the frog, her behavior changes from initially feeling flattered and impressed by his attention to becoming increasingly stressed, exhausted, and ultimately disillusioned.

    5. The audience's positive reaction initially fuels the nightingale's performances, providing her with validation and encouragement. However, their expectations and the pressure to please them ultimately contribute to her downfall.

    6. The nightingale's exhaustion and eventual demise symbolize the consequences of compromising one's integrity and succumbing to external pressures, leading to a tragic end.

    7. The frog rationalizes the nightingale's death by blaming her supposed lack of intelligence and ability to handle the demands of the stage, absolving himself of any responsibility.

    8. Through the characters of the frog and the nightingale, Vikram Seth explores themes of manipulation, exploitation, artistic integrity, the pursuit of success, and the dangers of conforming to societal expectations.

    9. The poem suggests that true artistic integrity and authenticity are paramount, emphasizing the importance of staying true to one's own voice and resisting the temptation to compromise for the sake of fame or external validation.

     

    10. The ending of the poem reflects the broader message conveyed by Seth by        highlighting the tragic consequences of sacrificing one's authenticity and integrity for the pursuit of success, serving as a cautionary tale against the perils of losing oneself in the pursuit of external validation and fame.

    9. What does the poem suggest about the nature of artistic integrity and authenticity? [ Long Answer] 

     

    The poem "The Frog and the Nightingale" by Vikram Seth suggests that artistic integrity and authenticity are fundamental to true artistic expression and fulfilment. Through the characters of the frog and the nightingale, Seth illustrates the contrast between genuine talent and the artificiality of conforming to external pressures.

    The nightingale represents natural talent and artistic authenticity. She possesses an innate gift for singing, and her initial performances are genuine expressions of her passion and ability. However, as she becomes entangled with the frog and succumbs to his manipulative guidance, her authenticity begins to erode. She compromises her style, technique, and artistic vision in an attempt to meet the frog's expectations and achieve success. Ultimately, this leads to her exhaustion and demise.

    On the other hand, the frog embodies the notion of artificiality and manipulation. He capitalizes on the nightingale's talent for his own gain, exploiting her abilities and manipulating her into a collaboration that serves his interests rather than hers. His focus is on profit and fame, rather than artistic expression or integrity.

    Overall, the poem suggests that true artistic integrity and authenticity cannot be compromised or sacrificed for the sake of external validation or success. The nightingale's downfall serves as a cautionary tale, emphasizing the importance of staying true to one's own voice, vision, and artistic values, even in the face of pressure or temptation to conform. By doing so, artists can achieve genuine fulfilment and leave a lasting impact through their art.

    MCQ’s

    1. What is the central character of the poem?

      1. Nightingale and Duck

      2. Frog and Nightingale

      3. Duck and Frog

      4. Heron and Loon

    2. What is the primary talent of the nightingale?

      1. Croaking

      2. Dancing

      3. Singing

      4. Swimming

    3. What is the initial reaction of other creatures to the frog's croaking?

      1. Admiration

      2. Disgust

      3. Indifference

      4. Fear

    4. Who becomes enchanted by the nightingale's singing?

      1. Toads

      2. Teals

      3. Tiddlers

      4. All of the above

    5. What does the frog promise the nightingale to convince her to collaborate?

      1. Fame and success

      2. Money and power

      3. Safety and shelter

      4. None of the above

    6. What is one criticism the frog offers about the nightingale's singing?

      1. It lacks force

      2. It lacks melody

      3. It lacks rhythm

      4. It lacks volume

    7. How does the nightingale's behaviour change as she becomes more involved with the frog?

      1. She becomes more confident

      2. She becomes more stressed

      3. She becomes more distant

      4. She becomes more indifferent

    8. What role does the audience's reaction play in the nightingale's performances?

      1. It boosts her confidence

      2. It causes her to become nervous

      3. It makes her question her talent

      4. It has no effect on her

    9. What is the significance of the nightingale's exhaustion and eventual demise?

      1. It symbolizes the dangers of overexertion

      2. It represents the consequences of compromising integrity

      3. It highlights the importance of rest and self-care

      4. All of the above

    10. How does the frog rationalize the nightingale's death?

      1. By blaming her for being prone to influence

      2. By acknowledging his role in her demise

      3. By attributing it to natural causes

      4. By denying any responsibility

    11. Which of the following animals is not mentioned in the poem?

      1. Owl

      2. Heron

      3. Sparrow

      4. Loon

    12. What do the animals do when the nightingale sings?

      1. Dance

      2. Cry

      3. Clap

      4. Sleep

    13. What publication does the frog claim to write for?

      1. Bog Gazette

      2. Swamp Times

      3. Bog Trumpet

      4. Frog Chronicle

    14. What does the nightingale ultimately die from?

      1. Old age

      2. Exhaustion

      3. Illness

      4. Accidental injury

    15. Who is the nightingale compared to by the frog?

      1. Beethoven

      2. Mozart

      3. Bach

      4. Chopin

    16. What does the frog charge admission for?

      1. Nightingale's performances

      2. Swimming lessons

      3. Croaking lessons

      4. None of the above

    17. Which animal weeps beneath the summer moon?

      1. Owl

      2. Duck

      3. Loon

      4. Heron

    18. What is the nightingale's initial reaction to the frog's criticism?

      1. She becomes defensive

      2. She becomes upset

      3. She becomes flattered

      4. She becomes indifferent

    19. What does the nightingale realize about her song by the end of the poem?

      1. It is perfect

      2. It needs improvement

      3. It has no delight

      4. It is too long

    20. What does the poem suggest about the pursuit of artistic integrity?

      1. It is easy to achieve

      2. It requires compromise

      3. It is essential for success

      4. It is irrelevant

    21. What does the nightingale initially feel about the frog's offer to collaborate?

      1. Excited

      2. Reluctant

      3. Indifferent

      4. Annoyed

    22. How does the frog convince the nightingale to continue singing in bad weather?

      1. By offering her shelter

      2. By providing encouragement

      3. By singing with her

      4. By demanding payment

    23. What does the frog claim to provide the nightingale during her vocal training?

      1. Warmth

      2. Confidence

      3. Instruction

      4. Criticism

    24. What do the animals do after the nightingale's death?

      1. Mourn

      2. Celebrate

      3. Ignore

      4. None of the above

    25. How does the frog react to the nightingale's demise?

      1. He mourns her loss

      2. He feels guilty

      3. He blames her

      4. He celebrates his own success

    26. What lesson does the poem convey about artistic collaboration?

      1. It leads to success

      2. It can be detrimental

      3. It is essential for growth

      4. It is always rewarding

    27. What emotion does the nightingale experience when the audience stops applauding?

      1. Relief

      2. Anger

      3. Sadness

      4. Indifference

    28. How does the frog perceive his own singing compared to the nightingale's?

      1. Inferior

      2. Superior

      3. Equal

      4. Unimportant

    29. What do the animals represent in the poem?

      1. The audience

      2. The critics

      3. The environment

      4. The society

    30. What does the nightingale's death symbolize in the poem?

      1. The end of music

      2. The triumph of the frog

      3. The loss of authenticity

      4. The cycle of life and death

    Answers

    1. B) Frog and Nightingale

    2. C) Singing

    3. B) Disgust

    4. D) All of the above

    5. A) Fame and success

    6. A) It lacks force

    7. B) She becomes more stressed

    8. A) It boosts her confidence

    9. D) All of the above

    10. A) By blaming her for being prone to influence

    11. C) Sparrow

    12. C) Clap

    13. C) Bog Trumpet

    14. B) Exhaustion

    15. B) Mozart

    16. A) Nightingale's performances

    17. C) Loon

    18. C) She becomes flattered

    19. C) It has no delight

    20. C) It is essential for success

    21. B) Reluctant

    22. C) By singing with her

    23. C) Instruction

    24. D) None of the above

    25. C) He blames her

    26. B) It can be detrimental

    27. C) Sadness

    28. B) Superior

    29. D) The Society

    30. C) The loss of authenticity

     

    ​

    bottom of page